September 1, 2025
From 'Can You Make It Pop?' to 'What's the ROI?': How Design Conversations Changed.
Design went from a nice-to-have craft function to a significant budget line that needs to demonstrate return on investment. Whether we like it or not, design is now evaluated with the same rigour as marketing, sales, and product development. The designers who thrive aren't abandoning craft—they're adding business fluency.
There was a time when the hardest question a designer faced was "Can you make the logo bigger?" or "Can this pop more?
Those were simpler days.
Today, designers are more likely to be asked: "What's the ROI of this redesign?" or "How will this impact our conversion metrics?" or "Can you quantify the business value of this work?"
The conversations around design have fundamentally shifted. Understanding why this happened, and what it means for your career, is no longer optional.
The Old Contract: Design as Service
For decades, design operated under an implicit contract: businesses hired designers to make things look good, and designers delivered aesthetically pleasing work.
Success was measured in subjective terms. Did the stakeholder like it? Did it look modern? Did it "feel right"?
Design was a service function. You were handed a brief, you created something beautiful, and you moved on to the next project. The value of your work was assumed, not measured.
This worked fine when:
Budgets were generous
Design teams were small and scrappy
Digital products were novel enough that good design alone was differentiating
Companies were growing fast enough that they didn't scrutinise every department's contribution
But that world is gone.
What Changed: Three Seismic Shifts
The professionalisation of design
As design matured as a discipline, it demanded a seat at the strategic table. Design leaders fought to be involved earlier in the product development process, to influence strategy, to shape business direction.
We won that fight. But with strategic influence comes strategic accountability.
When you're involved in setting direction, you're responsible for outcomes. You can't claim you should influence the product roadmap, then deflect when asked about results.
Economic pressure and accountability
The era of cheap money is over. Every department is being asked to justify its budget. "We believe design adds value" doesn't cut it anymore when finance teams are scrutinising every hire and every initiative.
Design went from a nice-to-have craft function to a significant budget line that needs to demonstrate return on investment. Whether we like it or not, design is now evaluated with the same rigour as marketing, sales, and product development.
The rise of metrics culture
Digital products generate unprecedented amounts of data. We can measure everything: how long users spend on a page, where they click, where they drop off, what drives conversions.
In this environment, every other discipline speaks in numbers. Marketing knows their CAC and conversion rates. Product knows their activation metrics and retention curves. Sales knows their pipeline and close rates.
Design was the last department still speaking in aesthetic terms while everyone else spoke in outcomes. That gap became untenable.
The New Questions (And Why They're Harder)
"Can you make it pop?" was easy to answer. Make it brighter. Add contrast. Use a bolder font. Done.
"What's the ROI?" is fundamentally different. It requires:
Understanding what to measure. Not every project has obvious metrics. How do you measure the impact of a design system? A rebrand? Accessibility improvements? Knowing which metrics matter for which type of work is a skill most designers never learned.
Tracking over time. ROI isn't instant. You need baseline metrics, you need to track changes, you need to account for external factors. This requires discipline and planning that most designers aren't trained in.
Speaking the language of business. When you say "improved user satisfaction," your CEO hears something different than when you say "increased NPS by 12 points, correlating with a 15% reduction in churn." One is vague. The other is strategic.
Connecting design decisions to business outcomes. The hardest part isn't tracking metrics. It's understanding the causal chain between your design choices and business results. How did simplifying the navigation impact revenue? Can you actually defend that connection?
This is why so many designers struggle with the new conversations. We were trained in composition and colour theory, not business strategy and metric analysis.
Why Some Designers Are Thriving
The designers who are advancing in this new environment aren't necessarily the most talented craftspeople. They're the ones who learned to bridge two worlds.
They still care deeply about craft. They still sweat the details. But they've also learned to:
Identify the metrics that matter for each project. They know that an e-commerce redesign needs different tracking than a SaaS onboarding flow or a content platform. They can look at a brief and immediately identify what success looks like in measurable terms.
Set baselines and track consistently. They don't wait until a project is finished to scramble for data. They establish baseline metrics before work begins, track changes throughout, and can show clear before-and-after comparisons.
Understand business context. They know what MRR means and why it matters. They understand customer acquisition costs and lifetime value. They can explain how design decisions influence retention, conversion, and revenue.
Communicate in outcomes, not activities. Instead of "I redesigned the checkout flow," they say "I streamlined checkout from six steps to three, reducing cart abandonment by 18% and representing approximately £240K in recovered annual revenue."
These designers aren't abandoning craft for spreadsheets. They're adding a crucial skillset that makes their craft more valuable and more defensible.
The Hidden Cost of Not Adapting
Here's what happens when you can't answer the new questions:
Your work becomes invisible to leadership. If you can't quantify impact, your contributions don't register in the conversations that matter. Other departments bring numbers to budget meetings. You bring passion. Guess who gets resources?
You get stuck in execution roles. Strategic roles go to people who can connect work to outcomes. If you can only talk about design process and aesthetic choices, you'll be forever executing other people's strategies rather than shaping them.
You're vulnerable when budgets tighten. In a restructure, the designer who can prove their work drove £500K in additional revenue is safe. The designer who made things "more intuitive" is at risk.
You lose opportunities. The best jobs, the promotions, the speaking opportunities all go to designers who can articulate business impact. Your portfolio might be brilliant, but if you can't talk about outcomes, you're invisible.
This Isn't About Becoming a Data Analyst
Some designers hear "track metrics" and think they need to become data scientists. They don't.
You don't need advanced statistical knowledge. You don't need to build dashboards or run complex analyses. You need to:
Know which 3-5 metrics matter for your specific project
Understand what those metrics mean and why stakeholders care
Track them consistently over time
Communicate the story they tell about your work's impact
This isn't about drowning in data. It's about having evidence for the value you create.
Looking Forward: Design's Next Chapter
The conversation isn't going back to "make it pop." Economic pressure isn't easing.
Metrics culture isn't going away. AI isn't making the need for strategic, business-fluent designers less important; it's making it more so.
The designers who will lead teams, influence strategy, and build lasting careers are those who can speak two languages fluently: the language of craft and the language of business.
The good news? This is a learnable skill. You don't need an MBA. You don't need to abandon what makes you a good designer. You need to add one more capability to your toolkit: the ability to measure, understand, and communicate your impact in business terms.
The conversations have changed. The question is: are you ready to change with them?
Ready to start tracking your design impact and building business fluency? Join the Uplift waitlist to be among the first to try the platform built specifically for designers navigating this new landscape.